16th May 2008

Comment Challenge Week 2

I’m not leaving my usual focus on all things visual, just adding my weekly report on an online blogging project I am participating in.


31 days commentingDay 8: Comment outside nicheIn order to comment outside my niche, I would have to have a niche. I write in an obscure area, and see my roles as varied, so my blog reader is full of a diverse range of topics. Good thing, it made it easy to complete this task, since it is already something I regularly do.

Day 9: Should we comment on blogs?

The thing I most appreciate about blogs is the diversity of approaches. If a blog is new, I recognize that someone may have not decided how they want to approach the blogosphere, but for a more mature blog, it seems reasonable that a blogger may make a variety of choices for reasons that are individual.

Day 10: Comment Audit

This day asked us to look at how our blogs might affect whether we get comments. Over the course of this blog, I think I have done everything on the list that might deter people. I still struggle over voice, who I am talking to, who I want to talk to, and who might care about what I have to say. Of course, this reflects some of my own confusion about the direction my business in general is moving. It’s an ongoing action research project. I try things, watch how they go, and redesign.

Day 11: Comment Policy

I have a bunch of redesign I am working on behind the scenes, so a comment policy will be added to it. I was particularly taken by Kevin’s concept, where he extends an invitation. So much more appealing to me than a policy per se.


Day 12: Comment Friendly?

Since this is a business blog, I do not feel comfortable taking moderation off for first time commentors. I have caught enough objectionable comments to feel comfortable with this.

Day 13: Post using comments

Since the comment challenge began, I have been writing posts based on reader comments or requests. It started with a comment on Sue Waters blog from Christy Tucker about her new blog header, and I responded with Does my header make my blog look fat? . Jabiz Raisdana asked about his headers on that post, so I wrote, What makes these blog headers effective? Then I got an email from Fred Deutsch so I wrote What to do with a visually noisy blog and Suggestions for a visually noisy blog.

I have enjoyed writing these posts since it has provided me concrete examples of visual patterns to demonstrate how they affect what we do online. I can’t do it all of the time, and it might be very boring after a while, but I hope it has been helpful to readers and the blog owners alike.

Day 14: Turn blog over to readers

Ok, so have you found the series on blog headers and patterns helpful? Interesting? What could I do to be more helpful? Any opinions, I’d love to hear them.

posted in Blogging | 8 Comments

7th May 2008

Week 1: Comment reflections

I’m not leaving my usual focus on all things visual, just adding a weekly report on an online blogging project I am participating in.


31 days commentingA group of bloggers from around the world have accepted the challenge to do something every day in May to become a better commenter on other blogs. Since I did another challenge last year with two of the organizers, I decided to join them. First, there are over a hundred blogs participating. The group in the last challenge was 14, so we got to know each other. It’s much harder to keep track of who is who this time. There are also networks of bloggers who have joined, and I’m noticing that it is harder to comment when it seems like all the other people in the comment string already know each other. Something to be aware of when I engage with my readers, or on blogs where I know others. What can I do to create a welcoming environment?

  • Day 1- Commenting self-audit

Commenting has always been somewhat sporadic for me. In phases. I read over 150 blogs, most of which I read the majority of the posts, so that alone is a major time commitment. I find when I am short on time, I skip the commenting. I’m also noticing I gather insights across the blogs I read, often making connections between tidbits that mash up with pieces offline. So the responses I find emerging don’t make sense attached to one place.If I knew ahead of time which tidbits were going to align, I might be able to write the type of posts rich with links that Sue Waters, Michele Martin, and Beth Kanter are so brilliant at doing. I seem to have a more retroactive thought alignment process rather than the anticipatory ones others seem to have that know what they might need and bookmark it for later.

  • Day 2- Comment on a new blog

This was easy. The comment challenge is full of blogs that are new to me. Since I train adults, I don’t follow K-12 blogs as a general rule, and the group has a lot of them. It’s been fun to explore them, they certainly have a different flavor. Not quite sure how to add value to the conversations on them yet. Instead I find myself telling those who are expressing anxiety about being behind that it’s OK. I guess I’m trying to find a common ground to share.

  • Day 3- Set up comment tracking

Like so many other things I discover on these challenges, the tracking software is a matter of strategizing how I am going to change the patterns of how I engage with daily practices. I center my online life around Google Reader and Mail, so things that integrate easily are the ones that I can adopt quickly. I have installed both co.mment and cocomment, but certainly have not fully adapted to them. And so far, I have found the RSS feeds from these tools to be confusing. Especially with so many similar conversations occurring across multiple blogs.

  • Day 4- ask a question in a comment

This is something I do with some regularity. What is interesting to me is how often bloggers ignore the questions I ask. Now I can understand if I ask another commenter a question that they may not see it. But as bloggers, we often get multiple notifications of comments. And I’m not talking just about the blogs with a huge amount of traffic. Leaves me wondering if it is the type of questions I ask, or the type of bloggers I’m asking.

  • Day 5- comment on a post I don’t agree with

By far the hardest task for me. This is totally contrary to my online behavior, and has sparked some of the deepest reflection. Offline, I certainly have no problem disagreeing with others. I suspect there are people around me who would say I voice my disagreement too much. So why is it so different for me online? I still haven’t figured it out, and I still haven’t disagreed.

  • Day 6 - engage with other commenters

It’s been nice to see the engagement with other commenters on the challenge. I have found it difficult to do this in the past. I read all/most of the comments on a post before I comment, and often try to engage with others. It’s almost like there are unspoken norms that develop on certain blogs. My favorites are the ones where the blogger and the readers talk freely and back and forth. I wonder what it takes to foster that norm?

  • Day 7 - 3 Learnings

The three things that jump out to me from the first week:

  1. Dedicated commenting takes an organized system to stay manageable
  2. I really don’t like the idea of disagreeing online
  3. There is a gap between what I like and what I am (not) creating on my own blog

posted in Blogging | 18 Comments

5th September 2007

Catching up with the 31day challenge

31 days challengeAugust was the month for the 31days to a better blog challenge. Only there weren’t enough hours in the day to get 31days of tasks done with all of the other things in my life. So, I have extended into September, and it may take even longer.

ShamilleIt’s not that I haven’t been working on this every day. Blogging is pretty simple to do, but very difficult to do well. All of the little details that make a difference collectively take time. Commenting, for example, can be really important to building community. In order to comment effectively, you have to read and think about the blog you are commenting on. MiniMeTakes time. And when you are reading a wide variety of blogs, there are endless links to follow and interesting paths to run off on. Soon enough, one cat is sitting on the keyboard reminding me her food is a higher priority while the others are trying cute, leg rubbing and other assorted tactics. They are pretty hard to resist.
Read the rest of this entry »

posted in Blogging | 3 Comments

28th August 2007

Learning about blogging on my bike

Banks-Vernonia bike trailI have been participating in the 31 days to a better blog challenge for 28 days, and I must say I will be sad when it ends. Not because I don’t have enough things to do to finish said challenge, as a matter of fact, it will probably take me more than another 31 days to do it. No, it’s the community of people who have formed around it. All slogging through a similar experience in very different ways. It’s been great journeying with you, and I hope it goes forward in some new form.

It’s hard to even isolate the daily tasks anymore, so I’m taking a new tack, and bringing forward a new type of reflection. At the beginning of the summer, I attended a workshop with Rita Bailey, during which we came up with an example to apply the learning. The result of which was me getting a new bike. This is the bike I rode in the Providence Bridge Pedal where I learned about Spontaneous Stereotyping and Storytelling. So I’ve been off riding again, this time on a 21 mile trail created on an old railroad bed. I learned a bit about training, and a realized a few things about blogging too. Read the rest of this entry »

posted in Blogging | 0 Comments

20th August 2007

31 day blogging challenge: Day 15 - 20

Building A Better Blog contest

Creative ways to manage challenge overload.

The challenge continues, and it continues to be challenging. The crew is getting creative in finding ways to get the TASK COMPLETED, Done clever checkbox, Progress = Completed :) Read the rest of this entry »

posted in Blogging | 0 Comments

14th August 2007

31 days blogging challenge: Days 11- 14

31 day blogging

The blogging challenge continues. It is getting harder and harder to execute the cumulative suggestions, keep up with all the other participants, keep commenting on their work, and execute all the ideas fostered by seeing what they are all doing. Especially multiplied by two blogs. And run a start-up business alongside my volunteer board work. I am still fully engaged, I am just having a hard time getting to everything. I am enjoying learning about all sorts of new things through the regular posts the challenge participants are writing beyond the challenge posts themselves. Read the rest of this entry »

posted in Blogging | 0 Comments

10th August 2007

31 day blogging challenge: Days 7 - 10

31 days challengeThe 31 day challenge continues. I wrote a reflection post on BlogCascadia the other day. Another aspect of this process I have noticed, is the group is starting to teach each other at new levels. The interaction is deepening. Read the rest of this entry »

posted in Blogging | 0 Comments

6th August 2007

31 Days Blogging Challenge- Days 2, 5 & 6

Building A Better Blog contest

Improve your blog, Improve your reach

I continue to work on the 31 Day blogging challenge, albeit in a bit of a random order, as time allows. Turns out, this was a good thing, as I learned more from my Day 2 ‘First time reader’ audit than I might have.
Read the rest of this entry »

posted in Blogging | 0 Comments

4th August 2007

31 Days to a Better Blog- Days 1-4

Building A Better Blog contestDarren Rowse from ProBlogger issued a challenge to spend time each day for 31 days to improve your blog. Michele Martin from The Bamboo Project asked her readers to join her in sharing the experience of applying the daily tips. I accepted the challenge from Michele to look at how I can improve the VisualsSpeak blog and the ASTD-Cascadia blog that I also administer and write for.

First impressions of the first four days- this is not going to be quick fixes and tips to transform your blog in five minutes or less. Like anything else, if it was easy, it wouldn’t be hard to be really good at it, so I shouldn’t be surprised. How to find the time to improve and continue to write for two blogs at the same time will be the first challenge.

Technorati Tags: , ,


Read the rest of this entry »

posted in Blogging | 0 Comments

30th June 2007

Other side effects of blogging.

A few weeks ago I wrote about the unexpected aspects of blogging. At that point, I was talking about the challenge of seeing myself as a writer, and the benefit of how blogging shifts and clarifies my thinking.

Where is the time to implement all these new ideas?
The practice of writing has given me insight into places in my business practices that aren’t as clear as they should be. It has been a catalyst for strategic re-evaluation. All this clarity is great, but how am I going to find the time in the day to implement this new found clarity. It’s like coming home from a powerful workshop or conference bursting with inspiration only to be greeted with the pile up of email, voice and snail mail (not to mention what can happen to the house).

I need to find a way to structure space. I can’t keep cramming new things into an already full space, whether it be physical, emotional, intellectual, or simply the hours in a day.

    What will I stop, start, and continue?
    How will I decide?
    How will I gain support for those decisions from those around me

Read the rest of this entry »

posted in Blogging, Inspiration | 0 Comments